I believe that there is a BOBB effect...in much of what I've read in the birthing blogosphere, there is a common refrain:
"I watched the Business of Being Born and it was then that...." which is ended in one of five ways:
a) "I decided on a home birth."
b) "I decided to avoid the 'cascade of interventions'."
c) "that a midwife was the best care provider for me and my baby."
d) "that freebirthing might even be an option for future children."
e) "I wanted to puke at all the misinformation and NCB bullshit."
The thing is that responses A-C are what 90 percent of the responses to that particular documentary are. Response D is also fairly rare (I'd say maybe 1 percent of women) and Response E only occurs among those who are skeptical enough to look for more information on birth and its risks.
What is dangerous is that the BOBB effect might be causing higher-risk women to push for non-interventionist births even when a more "hands-on" approach is safer for themselves and their babies. This might not be such a big deal in Canada where the regulations around midwives and their qualifications are pretty tight - but it might be in places like the US where regulations are more lax. I also wonder if it causes women to actively eschew tests that might demonstrate that they are higher risk, for fear of losing their preferred birth experience.
If there is a BOBB effect at work - it's not good - as at the end of the day babies and moms might be making some bad decisions when it comes to accessing appropriate care. Those bad decisions might lead to something far worse than an "unneccessarian" - a preventable death or a life-long disability.
It's time for the "Beyond Reason: The Religion of Being Born" to be produced - the anti-BOBB is needed, now more than ever.
A brave blog that strives to seek the truth and support women's rights to quality care, informed choice and timely access to medical care during labour and delivery... Healthy Mom, Healthy Baby should be the non-negotiable starting point.
Showing posts with label Natural Childbirth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Natural Childbirth. Show all posts
Monday, October 31, 2011
Sunday, October 30, 2011
The Perils of Mommy Group
I throughly enjoy my mommy group - we are all well-educated moms in our late twenties to mid-thirties with babies born within 2 months of each other. When we get together we talk about all sorts of thing....our husbands, our work (for those who went back to work), our kids and the joy of taming toddlers. All sorts of stuff. Last night, we had our "moms night out" it was quite enjoyable - we talked about saggy balls (apparently men in their geriatric years are also not immune to the effects of gravity), placenta consumption and other uses (for myself I just let it go the way of biohazardous waste or teaching material, although I had a very funny thought about a couple who are awaken in the middle of the night by raccoons fighting over a freshly "planted" placenta.....placenta is strewn everywhere in the morning....neighbors ask what it is....), work, the trials and tribulations of nap time/bed time/toddler discipline, mortgages...I am very happy to hear of the new pregnancy of one of my mommy friend. And then the conversation turned to birth.
I should have known better, I should have politely found an excuse to hurry home, but I didn't. And then I was there again, as the other women talked of all they did to speed up their labors and avoid the dreaded 'interventions'...I recall lying there hoping labour would stop or slow down, praying for a csection or at the very least an epidural...but more than anything praying that nothing would go sideways. My eyes glazed over and I starred at the red menu on the table....I tried to mentally absent myself from the conversation. It was hard to hear.... I think only one other mommy noticed my distress. My hand trembled as I reached for my water. Eventually the conversation ended and we departed, the drive home was difficult. My mind was still racing, my heart pounding. Upon my arrival home I poured myself two stiff cocktails to wind down from it.
Yep, I am nuts to consider #2....
I should have known better, I should have politely found an excuse to hurry home, but I didn't. And then I was there again, as the other women talked of all they did to speed up their labors and avoid the dreaded 'interventions'...I recall lying there hoping labour would stop or slow down, praying for a csection or at the very least an epidural...but more than anything praying that nothing would go sideways. My eyes glazed over and I starred at the red menu on the table....I tried to mentally absent myself from the conversation. It was hard to hear.... I think only one other mommy noticed my distress. My hand trembled as I reached for my water. Eventually the conversation ended and we departed, the drive home was difficult. My mind was still racing, my heart pounding. Upon my arrival home I poured myself two stiff cocktails to wind down from it.
Yep, I am nuts to consider #2....
Monday, October 24, 2011
Am I anti-'normal/natural' birth?
In general I would have to say that I am not anti-normal/natural birth.
I know that for myself, it's not an option that I like. It doesn't make me less of a mom. It doesn't make me a bad parent. It doesn't make me think that those who choose natural birth are somehow crazy for wanting that experience - nor do I think that those who enjoy that experience are 'weird'. Rather that given the information I know about myself, and information I know about birth - I prefer medicalized birth (ideally elective pre-labour c-section).
What I wish is that every woman was empowered with the information that she needed to make a choice that best meets her needs and the needs of her baby. This might be normal/natural birth, at a hospital or at a home - or it might be medicalized birth in a hospital.
I also wish that every woman was treated with respect - respect from her careproviders and respect from others about the decisions which are hers and hers alone to make.
So it's not about maternal choice c-sections, or maternal choice planned vaginal births. It's about maternal choice...and that choice should be fully informed and respected.
Quality care needs to be about meeting the needs of mothers and babies - healthy mom, healthy baby should be the goal and that includes physical as well as psychological health.
I know that for myself, it's not an option that I like. It doesn't make me less of a mom. It doesn't make me a bad parent. It doesn't make me think that those who choose natural birth are somehow crazy for wanting that experience - nor do I think that those who enjoy that experience are 'weird'. Rather that given the information I know about myself, and information I know about birth - I prefer medicalized birth (ideally elective pre-labour c-section).
What I wish is that every woman was empowered with the information that she needed to make a choice that best meets her needs and the needs of her baby. This might be normal/natural birth, at a hospital or at a home - or it might be medicalized birth in a hospital.
I also wish that every woman was treated with respect - respect from her careproviders and respect from others about the decisions which are hers and hers alone to make.
So it's not about maternal choice c-sections, or maternal choice planned vaginal births. It's about maternal choice...and that choice should be fully informed and respected.
Quality care needs to be about meeting the needs of mothers and babies - healthy mom, healthy baby should be the goal and that includes physical as well as psychological health.
Labels:
elective c-section,
Maternity Care,
Mrs. W,
Natural Childbirth
Thursday, October 20, 2011
The Disservice of Biased Information
I skipped out on the prenatal childbirth preparation classes - not to say that I didn't prepare myself for childbirth, I did - but I focussed my attention and education on surgical childbirth, as that was what I had planned on doing. I skimmed the other stuff (I went to the meet the doctor night at the hospital) - but mostly found that it confirmed what I did not want to do - give birth the 'normal' way. One of the reasons I opted out was that I perceived that I would be a poor fit in the traditional class - the maternal request c-section mom - no doubt I'd be singled out and potential ridiculed for my choice. I wasn't going to put myself in that position. This was a perception of bias (on my part) about the information that would be given in the class. Of the moms who did attend pre-natal class, they confirmed for me that indeed there was a 'natural childbirth' bias in the information given. Thanks, but, no thanks.
Unfortunately this left me somewhat flat-footed when I was faced with no other choice but to give birth 'naturally'.
I don't think biased information is limited to the 'natural childbirth community', I think the medicalised birth also has some degree of bias and perhaps an over emphasis on the avoidance of risk at all costs.
My problem is that I don't think there's much of a middle ground, and as a result women are left trying to decipher the information they receive about childbirth. For some women, likely those with higher levels of information literacy, they can sift through the information and make decisions that work best for them. Unfortunately for many women, they are ill-equipped to sift through the information in a way that identifies the bias (and corrects for it) and may make decisions that are less than ideal for themselves and their babies.
Good decisions that meet the needs of women and their babies would allow women to determine what matters most to them and which course of action is most likely to result in the most satisfaction when the job of parenting begins. I think this is the underlying problem with birth plans and can explain the sometimes large gap between what women expect of childbirth (and after) and what women actually experience of childbirth (and after).
The other big problem with bias, is that it tends to generate a paradigm where there is only one right way to give birth or parent. It generates the "if I didn't do it this way, I'm a failure" feeling and provides fertile ground for the development of "sanctimommies" and that is also damaging. Every woman should be able to stand by her decisions and say with conviction "I looked at the information available, and I made the choice that works for me and my child" with pride and with knowledge that it's okay to make a decision that is different from somebody else's decision.
Bias in information is bad, informed choice is good - but good choices rely on good (unbiased) information - a difficult challenge for any pregnant or birthing woman or parent today.
Unfortunately this left me somewhat flat-footed when I was faced with no other choice but to give birth 'naturally'.
I don't think biased information is limited to the 'natural childbirth community', I think the medicalised birth also has some degree of bias and perhaps an over emphasis on the avoidance of risk at all costs.
My problem is that I don't think there's much of a middle ground, and as a result women are left trying to decipher the information they receive about childbirth. For some women, likely those with higher levels of information literacy, they can sift through the information and make decisions that work best for them. Unfortunately for many women, they are ill-equipped to sift through the information in a way that identifies the bias (and corrects for it) and may make decisions that are less than ideal for themselves and their babies.
Good decisions that meet the needs of women and their babies would allow women to determine what matters most to them and which course of action is most likely to result in the most satisfaction when the job of parenting begins. I think this is the underlying problem with birth plans and can explain the sometimes large gap between what women expect of childbirth (and after) and what women actually experience of childbirth (and after).
The other big problem with bias, is that it tends to generate a paradigm where there is only one right way to give birth or parent. It generates the "if I didn't do it this way, I'm a failure" feeling and provides fertile ground for the development of "sanctimommies" and that is also damaging. Every woman should be able to stand by her decisions and say with conviction "I looked at the information available, and I made the choice that works for me and my child" with pride and with knowledge that it's okay to make a decision that is different from somebody else's decision.
Bias in information is bad, informed choice is good - but good choices rely on good (unbiased) information - a difficult challenge for any pregnant or birthing woman or parent today.
Wednesday, October 19, 2011
Is the 'Power to Push' campaign dangerous?
In BC there is a well known campaign that is called the Power to Push, and while at first glance it appears to support woman's choices in childbirth, it is decidedly "Pushy" about pushing natural child birth. This is particularly true of it's facebook page.
I have several concerns about the campaign. First, it's intended purpose is to 'push' down the Caesarean section rate in BC. Second, when discussing birth options, very few statistics are given about the relative risks of the options. Third, the benefits of medical intervention are downplayed. Fourth, the risks of natural birth are downplayed.
In short I think the campaign is irresponsible and I'm somewhat concerned that a major hospital (BC Children and Women's - the only hospital in BC with dedicated obstetric anaesthesiology) would support such a biased campaign.
Women need to be empowered to make decisions regarding birth - decisions that are safe and informed. Further, women need access to the services that support those decisions. Failing to provide unbiased and complete information (like real statistics on the risks and benefits) is irresponsible and dangerous.
I have several concerns about the campaign. First, it's intended purpose is to 'push' down the Caesarean section rate in BC. Second, when discussing birth options, very few statistics are given about the relative risks of the options. Third, the benefits of medical intervention are downplayed. Fourth, the risks of natural birth are downplayed.
In short I think the campaign is irresponsible and I'm somewhat concerned that a major hospital (BC Children and Women's - the only hospital in BC with dedicated obstetric anaesthesiology) would support such a biased campaign.
Women need to be empowered to make decisions regarding birth - decisions that are safe and informed. Further, women need access to the services that support those decisions. Failing to provide unbiased and complete information (like real statistics on the risks and benefits) is irresponsible and dangerous.
Monday, September 26, 2011
Is it time for a 'counter-revolution' in Birth?
There's another voice in the birth debate that has been squelched in the last couple of decades by those who view a 100% natural birth experience as being superior to the medical alternatives. There's a bias in childbirth education classes. There's a bias on the web. It's not a scientific bias - despite what Ina M. Gaskin and Rikki Lake might have you believe. Worse - it harms women and babies by restricting their choices and leading them to make decisions that wind up making them (and their babies) worse off. It makes women who do not subscribe to their beliefs feel as though they've failed in mothering or parenting.
The voice of the 'Natural Child Birth' (NCB) movement is exceptionally loud - they have their figureheads and their documentaries ("The Business of Being Born").
The counter-voice is quiet and must be sought out - it exists but it seems less charged. Where is the anti-NCB documentary "Beyond Reason: The Religion of Being Born"??.
The voice of the 'Natural Child Birth' (NCB) movement is exceptionally loud - they have their figureheads and their documentaries ("The Business of Being Born").
The counter-voice is quiet and must be sought out - it exists but it seems less charged. Where is the anti-NCB documentary "Beyond Reason: The Religion of Being Born"??.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)